I left local news in 2007 and returned in 2009. When I began covering stories again, I noticed one eye-opening change in the news market.
Radio news is different. WSB radio was the most relevant radio game in town in 2007. Nowadays, that relevance seems to belong to WABE.
I used to run into WSB radio reporters at stories regularly. Now I see WABE reporters. They covered the Atlanta mayor race consistently. WSB radio seemed puzzlingly absent.
I listen to both stations. WABE produces local news pieces each weekday on a variety of stories. WABE also regularly produces feature-length stories, like the clear-headed piece Odette Yousef delivered in November on the toothlessness of the Citizen Review Board, which reviews APD conduct.
By contrast, WSB is fixated on breaking news, plus every-six-minutes traffic and weather during drive times. It still does enterprise reporting, but very rarely.
WSB radio lost staff over the last few years, and now runs a skeleton crew. It leans pretty heavily on material from WSB-TV. Richard Sankster reliably covers overnight mayhem. Sandra Parrish covers the Capitol admirably.
As Rodney Ho notes, WSB’s ratings seem to be slipping, and WABE’s are surprisingly strong. However, radio ratings are unpredictable; it’s unlikely WABE will ever become a ratings leader. Audiences crave personalities, pop culture and mayhem. WABE delivers that stuff too sparingly for most.
The churn in the radio market isn’t surprising.
Radio news mattered a lot when I first started at WAGA in 1986. Back then, WGST was the city’s premier news station. WGST also carried talk shows by Neal Boortz and Clark Howard (as well as Dick Williams, Tom Houck, Mike Malloy, “Ralph from Ben Hill” and Tammy Lloyd).
Ludlow Porch
WGST went on its greatest tear when it snagged Braves baseball broadcasts from WSB, at the same time that the Braves went from worst-to-first in 1991. If you were on the radio in Atlanta, WGST was the place to be.
Meantime, WSB carried Ludlow Porch’s folksy but mostly irrelevant morning show. Its local news operation seemed to be a shadow of WGST, which audaciously called itself “the news monster.” Boortz lampooned WSB’s call letters, saying they stood for “we’re so boring.”
WSB fought back admirably, though. It jettisoned Porch, and grabbed Howard, Boortz and the Braves from WGST. For a few years, WGST tried to compete but couldn’t. It’s now a radio signal sadly carrying mostly syndicated programming, with no local news presence whatsoever. (See comments for a point of view disputing this observation.)
Overqualified: Odette Yousef, WABE
Enter WABE. It has a tiny staff. Its reporters almost never cover breaking news — apparently because WABE management knows NPR’s listeners aren’t interested in local carnage. It covers issues. It attends news conferences and city council meetings. Like other news organizations, it repackages stuff from other media and has plenty of room for improvement. But it’s smart and it’s relevant.
(Last Friday provided a great example. WABE ignored the “omigod it’s Armageddon” aspect of the snowfall. Its 8am local news covered gun rights, prison conditions and homeless issues. It only mentioned the weather during forecasts and just-the-facts recitals of traffic wrecks.)
Unlike web, newspaper and other broadcast media, WABE offers something genuinely unique: Wonky, commercial-free local radio news.
Speaking of wonky, Yousef actually plays that harp. Maybe she learned it at Harvard, where she got a degree in economics and east Asian studies and probably never listened to Joy Division.
Unlike its larger media brethren, WABE has a business model that may actually succeed. It’s dependent on fundraising, not commercials. If its management (owned by the Atlanta Board of Education, a whole ‘nother issue that I’ll leave alone here) doesn’t lose its nerve, WABE may be the “mainstream media” cockroach that sticks around long after the rest of us are wiped out.
Posted by Radio Executive on January 14, 2010 at 8:22 am
WSB is giving up news. You can hear it in their lack of segment time and lack of coverage. Nine months ago there were serious discussions to eliminate live news between 8pm and 4 am. This will eventually happen to 750. It is sad to see an important resource in the community change direction. Maybe if WGST had remained healthy with competition WSB would have countered. Thank you WABE for making my morning commute easier.
Posted by Tvshooter on January 14, 2010 at 9:16 am
“(Last Friday provided a great example. WABE ignored the “omigod it’s Armageddon” aspect of the snowfall. Its 8am local news covered gun rights, prison conditions and homeless issues. It only mentioned the weather during forecasts and just-the-facts recitals of traffic wrecks.)”
You mean they weren’t out warning drivers of the impending ice on the streets? Wow-that just makes me so cynical now, knowing that WABE was not standing at the top of a hill warning people or putting out a flare or something.
Posted by 2reporter on January 14, 2010 at 9:18 am
WSB radio is a point of contention for many of us on the television side.
Reporters work hours digging for stories with sources and footwork only to have radio lift these pieces without accreditation. They pull the sound and then pretend one of their radio voices broke the story or was covering it. Their news coverage is our news coverage. If you are going to steal our work at least mention the tv reporter or anchor. We all have complained loudly but it goes nowhere.
Newstalk 750. . . . Plagerism. . . .depend on it!
Posted by longgone on January 14, 2010 at 10:55 am
Some of the credit for local radio news gathering might go to John Weatherford… former WAGA reporter/producer and one-time edit house owner (now a head honcho at WABE). He has taken over an admittedly skeleton operation and given it purpose. They do a lot with a little. This is just a guess on my part, but John has always loved radio, news and fine music.
Posted by jcburns on January 14, 2010 at 11:07 am
A couple of years ago we gave up on WABE…back when both the news and basic board-running announcer talent seemed hopelessly second-rate for a city of this size, and their scheduling left many of the NPR News offerings OFF their air. We then used the magic of the internet to listen to…and we financially supported…WUNC Chapel Hill. So I hadn’t really tuned in to a lot of the positive changes which I too would attribute to Weatherford’s caring about news…and was pleasantly surprised when some increased travel around town got me to listening to the station again.
Odette Yousef, Denis O’Hayer, and colleagues are doing a wonderful job of covering a town filled with important stories.
We’re back to (happily) giving to WABE because of their vastly improved local news efforts…kinda wish we could designate our contribution to go 100% to local news reporters’ salaries.
Posted by news whiz on January 14, 2010 at 11:36 am
Radio news doesn’t make money. Boortz and Howard do. Those who listen to the station want opinion, traffic and weather. Times have changed. News is out.
Posted by Juliea on January 14, 2010 at 4:30 pm
WABE is much improved, but could we possibly get something other than non-stop classical music throughout the day? Holy Kamoley!
Posted by Gagarin on January 14, 2010 at 7:58 pm
I wish they would stop playing that damn classical music.
Posted by rptrcub on January 14, 2010 at 8:21 pm
But my *real* favorite is after the morning news, when Lois Reitzes is on her second cup, usually of Irish coffee the way she sounds.
Posted by Photoggg on January 14, 2010 at 9:21 pm
One can only applaud the efforts of WABE news staff. Denis O’Hayer and Odette Yousef are among the best journalist in Atlanta. However, WABE’s management team lead by Lois Reitzes seem to be in a quest to deprive Atlanta of the best of the local news team as well as the national programing of NPR. For years now, the Creative Loafing has been the sole outlet reporting on the lack of NPR programing on 90.1 which favors many hours of classical music instead. The Loafing has blamed Cox enterprises, owner of WSB radio and the AJC for the lack of NPR between Morning Edition and The World accusing it of conflict of interest. Apparently Cox is among the biggest contributors to WABE and does so to keep NPR programing, such as Talk of the Nation, from competing with local powerhouses Neil Bortz and Clark Howard. WABE favors the classics even thou the donations it asks for twice a year pays for all NPR programing and chooses not to air them. A story from October of ’03 ( http://tinyurl.com/wabestory ) documents the efforts of local residents failing to convince Reitzes and the Atlanta Board of Education to increase NPR programing. What a shame, it would be nice to have the option to listen to intelligent shows, including locally produced ones on 90.1. I would love to see a revival of “60 at 6″, heck, I’ll settle for “30 at 6″ to allow Marketplace to keep its time slot.
Perhaps an enterprising reporter, or blogger, could do an open records request to find out who its contributors are and how is the money spent at WABE.
Posted by LBJ on January 14, 2010 at 11:32 pm
I am very grateful that WABE is delivering news that matters and has hosts like Steve and Denis we can enjoy listening to. Maybe WSB will learn something before they slide into oblivion – do we really care if there’s yet another apartment fire, if we’re not in it? The thing that WABE must change is the horrible website. Can’t WABE have its own site…with a schedule we can read?
Posted by excalibur on January 15, 2010 at 8:08 am
Doug, thanks so much for your entertaining and informative blog. I read it every day!
However, as a WGST employee, I have to say that your comment that we have “no local news presence whatsoever” is both inaccurate and hurtful. Allow me a chance to set the record straight…
While things have changed from the “Newsmonster” days, the fact is we still have a dedicated team of professionals working every day to provide local news on WGST and the 100+ station Georgia News Network. Like WSB and WABE, we had members of our news staff sleeping in the studios last Thursday night to stay on top of the WX. We have reporters who work the phones hard on breaking stories. We still work to provide extensive legislative coverage. And we are only unstaffed during the overnight hours.
Last year, we won 8 AP Awards, including Best Newscast. Only WSB won more.
While it’s true that our limited resources make it difficult for us to get out in the field, and while it’s true that we rely heavily on our news partners at WAGA to fill the gaps, to say that we are non-existant is wrong and demeaning.
This is not to take away from your (correct) original message, that WABE does a terrific job with their local news coverage despite limited resources. Dennis is one of the best in the city. We share news tips with WABE every day. Incidentally, we also occasionally get calls from 11 Alive’s Information Center to share news tips.
Posted by dinko on January 15, 2010 at 2:56 pm
Excalibur,
Not to be mean, but you guys are not on the arbitron ratings radar, nor the car buttons of anyone I know. A proud station nuked by out of town managers. Those of us who have lived here most of our lives can’t be fooled by a long winded post.
WGST-R.I.P. The end of WGST has not helped WSB, however, it has helped WABE in the vacuum.
Dinko
Posted by HistoryJoe on January 16, 2010 at 12:35 am
Excellent topic, WABE has vastly improved in the last 2 years for local news coverage and should be applauded. I’ve been listening since 1992 when I was listening to 750 AM the rest of time (remember the Braves?) and never heard it better from 90.1 than the last few years.
Posted by gooberpeas on January 16, 2010 at 1:33 am
for what it’s worth, I enjoy the classical music…..that’s about the only reason I listen to WABE…when travelling, as I get out of range of one station, I move up the dial to the next NPR station and generally get classical music for most of the trip.
Posted by arky on January 16, 2010 at 9:30 pm
Why is WABE able to do so much field work with so few people? It doesn’t hurt that they do, by my count, only 11 newscasts a day. By contrast, WGST does 27 and WSB does 48.
And to “2reporter,” you realize you guys are all part of the same company, right? You’re lucky they mention the TV station at all. When you grab material off the AP wire for your national tells, do you credit them? Do you give a courtesy to ABC when you pull video off of NewsOne?
Posted by 2reporter on January 17, 2010 at 3:24 pm
Newsone is a feed service.
AP’s prime directive is that of content provider.
WSB Television is not a feed service but the historic leader of news and information for North Georgia. We are providers of news to our viewers not to our friends in the Cox building basement of West Peachtree. The bulk of WSB radio news content is taken from WSB television. Anyway you cut it, it’s plagerism.
Posted by English major on January 19, 2010 at 11:57 pm
2reporter: no, it’s plagiarism. And on the radio, mis-spellings don’t matter.
Posted by itpdude on January 28, 2010 at 3:08 am
I switched off news radio sometime after the run-up to the Iraq invasion of 2003. I could not listen, the situation was so frustrating. But being a bit of a news junky, I had to listen to something and non-news was getting boring so I tried the commies over at NPR. To my amazement, I liked it. Further to my amazement, I found out not all of them were pinko commies.
I haven’t looked back, however, I wish there was some sort of all day news radio station, particularly FM. The AM around Atlanta can really suck with all the buildings, high power wires, and bridges.
And does WGST even have an antennae anymore?
Posted by JOEBOY on October 22, 2011 at 5:24 pm
WABE is as relevant as an Obama campaign speech ! No one listens, no one believes!