Friday noir

Why's it gotta be "black" Friday?  Justin Gray, WAGA

Why's it gotta be "black" Friday? Justin Gray, WAGA

“Black Friday” is a term only recently introduced into the media lexicon.  The busiest-shopping-day ever phenomenon is generations old.  But the term — and the tendency of stores to encourage pre-dawn shopping — are 21st century developments.   Can’t say that either of them advances the human condition one iota.

Likewise, this increasingly insidious phenomenon keeps legions of high-seniority TV reporters at work during what should be a laid-back holiday.  Sadly for them, the retailers of America are now governing their schedules.  Now, the best Black Friday stories are the ones you probably aren’t watching — the ones that appear on morning or noon newscasts.

It’s a good story to cover.  It’s mostly a one-stop shop.  The story subjects are usually in good humor and willing to be interviewed.  The competitive threshold is low.  The challenge is delivering a story that isn’t completely predictable.  Half the battle is finding interviewees who are interesting.  One oddball character can often make the difference between a ho-hum piece and a memorable Black Friday story.

Geeked up on mimosas and tryptophan, we choked down ten Black Friday stories– a fraction of the content delivered by the four Atlanta TV stations.  Noteworthy:

Justin Gray’s piece on WAGA at noon Friday was the best of the bunch.  Sharply written and edited, its narrative included the overnight buildup through the moment that a NW Atlanta Wal-Mart opened its doors and beyond.   Gray’s piece was the most thoughtfully produced that we saw.  Plus, he lucked into a shopper who was hilariously obsessed with buying a 32″ flat screen TV.  Grade:  B+

No time, pal.  Julie Wolfe, WXIA

No time, pal. Julie Wolfe, WXIA

Tony McNary’s story on WGCL Wednesday night had a couple of not-so-predictable moments.   He was with a line full of folks awaiting the opening of a Best Buy store.  One of them admitted to showing up at 4am Wednesday to form the queue.  It took 14 hours for another shopper to join her.  D’oh!  McNary also found a shopper who was amusingly incredulous that all those folks would waste their time in a line for a store to open.  Grade:  B

At WXIA, Julie Wolfe pulled an overnight shift and for her effort, delivered a vo/sot at Discover Mills at 6:30am or so.  Wolfe is a talented package producer, but we could only find this vo/sot on WXIA’s website.  It concluded with an amusing and awkward encounter with Santa, who strolled into her shot as she concluded, apparently expecting to be interviewed.  Wolfe had to explain to the Old Elf that she was out of time, but would get around to it later.  Grade:  Incomplete.

WSB’s Tiffany Reynolds produced a piece shot at the outlet mall in Dawsonville, an above-and-beyond distance to travel for a Black Friday story.  It was a worthwhile locale; the video gave the story a more energetic feel than we saw in most other pieces.  Too bad there were no interesting characters in it.  Grade:  B-

Valerie Hoff, WXIA

Valerie Hoff, WXIA

With WXIA’s newscast-deadening obsession with live vo/sots, Valerie Hoff took advantage of the lighter workload by procuring a hard-to-find toy for her son, and displaying it in a live shot at noon Friday.  Hoff played it straight, but anchor Jill Becker called her out on it.  Hopefully, Hoff is among the many TV newsies who don’t allow their young children to watch their product.  Grade:  Busted.

This entry was posted in WAGA, WGCL, WSB, WXIA on by .

About live apt fire

Doug Richards is a reporter at WXIA-TV. This is his personal blog. WXIA-TV has nothing whatsoever to do with this blog, under any circumstances, in any form. For anything written herein, Doug accepts sole credit and full blame. Follow him on Twitter: @richardsdoug. All rights reserved. Thanks for visiting.

7 thoughts on “Friday noir

  1. live apt fire Post author

    Hi Shawn– vo/sot stands for “voice over / sound on tape.” Anchors perform them in studio all the time. It means that an anchor reads the material live while video plays, then pauses for a soundbite.

    Most reporters cover stories and produce packages, which include pre-recorded voice tracks, soundbites and hits of natural sound. A package showcases a reporter’s storytelling ability, and the reporter’s (and photog/editor’s) ability to blend visual and audio elements into something that approaches a “complete” story.

    WXIA often asks reporters to perform live vo/sots in lieu of packages, presumably to save time. I think that if reporters are going to spend all day covering a story, let them showcase their storytelling skills. And if it has to be shorter, make ’em do a shorter package.

    Given the high skill level of many WXIA reporters as package producers, it seems to me to be a waste to have them do live vo/sots, which looks and sound like a throwaway coverage.

    My two cents of course. Thanks for asking.

  2. daryll

    I find almost all of the Black Friday stories to be re-gifted from previous years and less than compelling. The thought of Paul Yates or Richard Belcher pulling duty on one of these nonsensical stories is depressing. Give them the day off and give them a real assignment. There are plenty of reporters on Atlanta TV born after the creation of MTV who can “handle” these non-news time fillers.

    Nice clean explanation of VO-SOT. I would love to hear your director’s track critic in real time of any of the local newscasts in Atlanta. Sounds like an opportunity for TomorrowVision.

  3. gooberpeas

    this is the time of year that I watch the least amount of tv news…I’ll try to catch the weather and then change the channel to something interesting…..I really don’t care to hear about how crowded the malls are and how much people are spending, or how worried retailers are…..and like the previous poster said, it’s just the same old stories anyway.

  4. Pingback: Atlanta blogs today | Fresh Loaf

  5. John

    Local TV coverage of Black Friday. As nauseating and repetitive as its coverage of holiday airport travel.

    “Airport officials expect busy days. Parking will be difficult [except for live TV trucks that get primo spaces]. If you are flying, be sure to arrive early.”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s