Mise en scene

We’re the first to admit this blog isn’t timely.  But Sarah Palin, who visited Georgia this week, will apparently never become passé.  Palin’s post election exploits remain improbably au courant. One of our favorite local pols is proudly circulating his photo with Palin on Facebook, the image captured at a Gwinnett Co. rally Monday.  And this week, two cute old lady bloggers analyze her (and Max Cleland) in a post called “Sarah Palin’s accomplishments are greater because she did it with half a brain.”

But we’re here to take a moment to explore the most controversially-framed TV interview in recorded history.

Lenslinger’s take on the incident is pretty dead on.  The turkey-killin’ guy in the background spent way too long staring at the camera.  That was the distraction that would have cued most photogs to zoom past him and tighter onto the face of Palin.  His gruesome task isn’t really evident until about forty seconds into the interview, long after the grim reaper of fowl breaks off his unsettling stare.

The photog is an Anchorage guy named Scott Jensen.  Turns out Jensen is well known and well respected in the photog community.  He showed up late for the interview.  His framing was somewhat the result of having the last tripod on scene.  From Viewfinder Blues:

Jensen then framed his shot just as it appears, even warning the Governor of the ensuing slaughter so clearly visible behind her. “That’s fine,” Palin reportedly replied, “Let the people see where their food comes from.”

To his credit, Jensen has defended his work on b-roll.net.

‘I’m a photojournalist. It is my goal to convey every scene I shoot as close to reality as possible. I want truthfulness over tastefulness – every time. From my perspective the background dominated the scene. It wasn’t way off in the distance. It was like ten feet away! Guess what?! It really was distracting! Ask anyone who was paying attention. The video I made portrayed the scene exactly. I believe that is what we are supposed to do.”

It’s a good argument.  It’s also problematic.  Aside from the distraction, it made Jensen seem to be either a) clueless or b) a partisan enemy of the politician he’s videotaping.  Surely his instinct kicked in and said “this ain’t right,” even after Palin gave him the go-ahead to shoot with the slaughtering operation behind her.

Many photogs would have halted the interview and said “Governor, sorry, but neither you nor I want this in the background.”  Photogs do control their background, bypassing “truthfulness over tastefulness.”  The pro sports locker room is an excellent example.

And yet, history will show that Jensen made the right call.



Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized on by .

About live apt fire

Doug Richards is a reporter at WXIA-TV. This is his personal blog. WXIA-TV has nothing whatsoever to do with this blog, under any circumstances, in any form. For anything written herein, Doug accepts sole credit and full blame. Follow him on Twitter: @richardsdoug. All rights reserved. Thanks for visiting.

6 thoughts on “Mise en scene

  1. newzfinland

    That Mo-Ron behind her is priceless. Personally, I didn’t find it that offensive or gross, just distracting. Made it even tougher to follow her constant, mindless droning of “talking points.”

    Reply
  2. LBJ

    A little over a year from now we’ll start seeing ads from candidates for Guv’ner of Georgia. If they say they’re for the death penalty, let’s have ’em stand in front of the lethal injection table…

    Reply
  3. Pingback: Atlanta blogs today | Fresh Loaf

  4. scott hedeen

    Jensen is the NPPA camerman of the year. Now… given… not until Palin hit the scene… was their any news in Alaska that would warrant a photog needing to extend their talents beyond the occasional feature story? you gotta fill the news cast in Nome with something!..(.a 5:00 slo mo beauty shot of the sunset helps!)

    This said… really… Jensen shouldve adjusted the shot. It’s a great piece of tape… surely… but does it add or distract from the story. Video JOURNALIST is someone who knows what the story is…. Is this about turkey killing? if it was… then awesome.. if it wasnt… good god man… use that zoom. Frame it. I learned along time ago in the news biz (yes… i’m not in “it” anymore… so this arm chair i’m quarter backing from feels so nice!)… never give anyone any piece of tape you don’t want to have yr name on. I’ve heard the complaints about shakey video …”The editor just took the first three shots!”… well… make sure yr raw tape starts off with the best shots. Think before you roll. In this case… Jensen’s framing has become a YouTube hit.. rather than a story he was out to cover.

    of course… in the long run… it think that turkey got a better treatment than what Palin did to McCain’s White House try.

    Reply
  5. scott hedeen

    also… Doug… great use of a classic film phrase. A film major in college… at my first TV job… when sent out for a MOS (man on the street)… i thought …”ooh. Mise En Scene!”… so i went out and shot a wide shot of the street corner. Huzzah Jean Luc Godard!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s