More with less

Sans jammies:  Sam Crenshaw, WXIA

Sans jammies: Sam Crenshaw, WXIA

Given the fact that Gannett has had to furlough employees in 2009, it would have seemed downright criminal for WXIA to cover the start of baseball’s spring training with its usual compliment of reporters, anchors, photographers and live truck operators.  Yet the story is high interest.  And with Orlando but a one-day drive away, the Atlanta media have traditionally covered it on-site.  So WXIA apparently sent Sam Crenshaw and a photographer.  And Crenshaw has been delivering live reports via Skype, the streaming-video web thing that is becoming increasingly popular among TV stations cutting corners.  It works.

Crenshaw has been delivering reports via Skype on WXIA’s newscasts from morning to night (“Sammie in his jammies!” exclaimed Fred Kalil about Crenshaw’s Skype reports on the station’s 5 – 7am newscasts).  Skype looks as cheap as it is, delivering a stop-action picture that’s so crude, WXIA would only play Crenshaw’s 6pm live shot Tuesday in the studio monitor.  It never took the shot full-screen, as it would a normal satellite or microwave live shot.

But if Crenshaw is just sitting and talking, voicing over clean tape fed in earlier, there’s no real harm.  And it benefits the station by enabling it to work Crenshaw like a dog.  Live trucks are problematic. Satellite time is expensive.  And live truck operators, with their troublesome commercial driver’s licenses, are restricted from working round-the-clock by the US DOT.  Skype has no such restriction.  If Sammie can set up his camera-equipped lappy in his jammies, he can do a live shot on TV without a live truck operator or even a photographer.  Woo-hoo.

Skype has other benefits.  While in DC last month, we saw a WRC reporter do Skype live shots on a moving train on the city’s Metro transit system.  Because Metro has solid cell phone service, Skype was reliable.  And the live shot couldn’t have taken place with the reporter tethered to a traditional live truck.

(Skype also enabled some stations to cover the inauguration with craven cheapness, sending reporters on buses with local supporters and having them fend for themselves on two-day trips from places like Florida and Iowa.  It gave the TV stations a “presence,” suitable for their promotion.  But the logistics were often nightmarish, and the coverage was likely very one-note).

TV news has been hoping for this technology for decades.  Skype is still very, very flawed;  if a reporter wants to do a live shot at an active scene in a local neighborhood, his stop-action Skype shot will make it look like he’s reporting from Baghdad, while his competitor does a clean shot with traditional microwave technology.  But this is the proverbial foot in the door.  Given the ugly contraction in the traditional media economy. it probably can’t happen soon enough.

6 thoughts on “More with less

  1. localtvnews

    As always, great post, and dead on. As a “bus rider” in this multiplatform more with less world, I can attest to one other certainty: producers and managers, once they’ve gotten “video” or “live” without rolling a truck, INSTANTLY forget there’s a new, not-quite-there-yet technology being tested and tweaked. From the moment I fed a :35 standup by laptop from a moving bus (which took nearly 45 minutes to upload), my cell phone was ringing with shouted requests to “feed tease video ASAP!”

    Well, with our laptop, aircard, and DV cam setup, there wasn’t anything ASAP about it. And you know as well as I, driving north toward Savannah in the middle of the night, well, you’re hitting spots not known for high speed cell service. The 11? If not for a Houston’s with Wi-Fi… forget it.

  2. daryll

    Why be “proud as a peacock” to offer HD news only to have “You Tube” quality field video? The door to cheap just got blown off its hinges.

    Sounds like backpack journalism should get the same kind of acceptance, too.

  3. Austin Rhodes

    Pretty ironic that this technology commentary centers on Sam Crenshaw. When Sam and I worked together at Channel 12 in Augusta, in addition to straight news reporting I was also his #2 sports guy.

    On Football Friday Nights i took great pride in shooting action from the sidelines, I really enjoyed it and got pretty good at it.

    Sam pulled me aside one night and said: “…man…you are hanging yourself! They are gonna have you all over Hell’s half acre shooting stuff by yourself…”

    That was almost 20 years ago.

    How ironic are those comments given these latest developments?

    That said, my dear old friend Sam continues to be an asset to WXIA, and I hope they always respect his talent and his work ethic. The man is as solid as they come!

  4. Laurel

    This post is just one of the reasons I’m choosing to get out of this biz. “Broadcast quality” is just no longer the case.

  5. Don B

    Good God, this discussion sends my blood pressure up. I think I’ll stop reading and have another beer. Oh yes, that’s better. Thank goodness I don’t have to worry about news live shots any more.

  6. Macon Peach

    “Broadcast quality” now is anything you can get on the air. The national networks do it so why not local affiliates. Disgusting.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s